Male Statues & Their Appendages, Florence – Why Aren’t They Very Well Endowed?

Have you ever looked closely at the male statues in Florence? Italy‘s artistic heritage includes a wealth of classical male statues. These sculptures are displayed in museums, piazzas, and gardens, each revealing a unique story related to history, mythology, and artistic ideals. However, one striking detail often noticed – sometimes humorously, sometimes curiously – is that these statues tend to have rather small appendages or genitalia.

After reading an intriguing article titled “Why Aren’t Classical Statues Very Well Endowed?“, I was reminded of my trip to Florence and decided to take a closer look at my own photos of some of the city’s most famous male statues.

The article, referencing art historian Elen Oredsson, explains:

“As it turns out, a lot has changed over the last few thousand years, including how we think about penis size. Elen Oredsson of the blog How to Talk About Art History explains in one post that ‘cultural values about male beauty were completely different back then. Today, big penises are seen as valuable and manly, but back then, most evidence points to the fact that small penises were considered better than big ones’.”

With this in mind, let’s explore the historical significance of famous male statues in Florence and why classical sculptors made the artistic choices they did.

Boboli Gardens: A Living Museum

The Boboli Gardens are more than just a beautiful green space. They are an open-air museum filled with centuries-old oak trees, elegant fountains, and magnificent sculptures. The gardens began taking shape in the 15th century under the powerful Medici family and expanded over the next four centuries into the vast, elaborate park visitors see today.

Two male statues in particular stand out here: the Fountain of Neptune and the Fountain of Bacchus.

Fountain of Neptune

This statue of Neptune, the god of the sea, stands proudly in the garden. His powerful physique represents his dominance over water. However, like many other classical statues, his genitalia are noticeably small. This follows the ancient Greek and Roman tradition of associating smaller genitalia with wisdom, self-control, and heroism rather than animalistic desires.

Fountain of Bacchus

In contrast to Neptune, Bacchus, the god of wine and excess, is depicted as overweight and drunk, riding a turtle in an almost comical pose. His rounded belly and relaxed stance reflect his association with pleasure, indulgence, and lack of restraint. While still following classical artistic conventions, Bacchus’ figure starkly contrasts Neptune’s muscular, disciplined appearance.

The Boboli Gardens, with their mix of mythical figures and artistic mastery, offer a glimpse into the values and aesthetics of Renaissance Florence, deeply rooted in the traditions of ancient Greece and Rome.

Piazza della Signoria: A Political and Artistic Hub

Replica of the Statue of David

Of the male statues in Florence, the Statue of David is the most famous. The original statue, housed inside the Accademia Gallery, is one of the most recognised sculptures in the world. However, a replica stands outside the Palazzo Vecchio in the Piazza della Signoria, where the original once stood.

David, depicted before his battle with Goliath, is the ultimate symbol of intelligence, courage, and defiance. His physique is perfectly proportioned, except, notably, for his genitals. In the classical tradition, a large penis was often associated with foolishness or lack of control, whereas a smaller one was linked to intelligence and virtue – qualities David was meant to embody.

Neptune’s Fountain

Neptune’s Fountain in Florence’s Piazza della Signoria is an impressive Renaissance masterpiece. Designed by Bartolomeo Ammannati and completed in 1575, it was commissioned to celebrate Florence’s naval power. The statue of Neptune, made from white Carrara marble, stands tall in the centre, surrounded by playful bronze sea creatures.

Like many classical male statues, Neptune’s anatomy has been a topic of discussion. The sculptor followed Renaissance traditions, portraying the male form in a way that emphasised balance and proportion rather than exaggeration. Over time, the fountain has faced weathering, vandalism, and even humorous pranks – at one point, people used it for laundry! Despite this, it remains a symbol of Florence’s artistic heritage.

Hercules and Cacus

Standing opposite David is Hercules and Cacus, a male statue by Baccio Bandinelli, commissioned by the Medici family. Unlike David, who represents the Republic’s fight against tyranny, Hercules represents brute strength, overpowering the monstrous Cacus.

Interestingly, while Hercules is shown in an idealised, muscular form, his genitals follow the same classical artistic conventions – small and understated. Despite his overwhelming physical power, he is still depicted as a figure of discipline and heroism rather than raw aggression.

The placement of these statues side by side speaks volumes about Florence’s turbulent political history. David symbolised the Republic’s resistance, while Hercules represented the Medici’s return to power and dominance over the city.

Loggia dei Lanzi: A Gallery of Mythology in Stone

Adjacent to the Piazza della Signoria is the Loggia dei Lanzi, an open-air museum showcasing some of Florence’s most dramatic and expressive sculptures. Each male statue tells a gripping mythological tale, reinforcing the Renaissance fascination with classical stories.

Hercules and Nessus

This sculpture depicts Hercules battling Nessus, the centaur who tried to abduct his wife, Deianira. The struggle between the two figures is intense, capturing a moment of movement and tension. Once again, Hercules is presented as the ultimate warrior, and as expected, his genitalia remain modest in size – consistent with the classical ideals of control and virtue.

Perseus Holding the Head of Medusa

One of the most striking male statues in the Loggia is Benvenuto Cellini’s Perseus, holding up the severed head of Medusa. This bronze masterpiece was meant to be a political statement, symbolising the Medici’s power crushing their enemies.

Like David, Perseus is depicted as poised and heroic, reinforcing the Renaissance admiration for balanced, rational figures. His anatomy follows the same artistic conventions, ensuring that his portrayal aligns with the classical ideals of beauty and intellect.

Menelaus Supporting the Body of Patroclus

This moving sculpture shows Menelaus, the king of Sparta, holding the dying Patroclus, Achilles’ closest companion. The scene is tragic and emotional, emphasising loyalty, friendship, and the harsh realities of war.

Even in a scene of death and sorrow, the classical style remains – both warriors are muscular and idealised, yet their genitals are proportionally small, consistent with ancient artistic traditions.

The Rape of the Sabine Women

Perhaps the most dynamic sculpture in the Loggia dei Lanzi, The Rape of the Sabine Women by Giambologna, captures a chaotic moment of struggle between three figures. The twisting, upward-reaching movement of the figures showcases the artist’s mastery of anatomy and emotion.

Despite the intense drama of the scene, the male figures conform to the same classical ideals: strong and athletic, yet with understated genitals, reinforcing the association between physical perfection and controlled masculinity.

So, Why Aren’t Classical Statues Well Endowed?

Looking at all these male statues in Florence, the pattern is clear: male figures in classical art were deliberately sculpted with small genitalia. But why?

Cultural Values and Masculinity

In ancient times, self-control, intelligence, and virtue were prized traits in men. Large genitalia were linked to foolishness, lust, and lack of restraint. In Greek comedies, oversized phalluses often symbolised crude, uncultured characters, while gods and heroes had smaller, refined features, emphasising their wisdom and nobility.

Philosophers like Aristotle associated small genitalia with rationality, while “barbarians” or uncivilised people were sometimes depicted with exaggerated features to highlight their lack of discipline.

Aesthetic Ideals and Artistic Proportions

Greek sculptors, following strict rules of proportion, such as Polykleitos’ Canon, aimed for balance and harmony. Large genitalia would have disrupted the symmetrical beauty they sought to achieve. The ideal male body was muscular and poised, with every feature complementing the whole rather than drawing attention to any one part.

Symbolism in Myth and Art

Many male statues represented gods and legendary heroes, embodying perfection. Their sculpted forms reflected not just physical strength but also moral superiority. David, Hercules, and Perseus all follow this convention, reinforcing their status as disciplined and virtuous figures.

In contrast, mythical creatures like satyrs and fauns, known for indulgence and excess, were depicted with exaggerated genitalia to emphasise their uncontrolled nature.

Separating Humans from Beasts

To ancient Greeks and Romans, self-restraint distinguished humans from animals. Larger genitalia were often used to depict creatures driven by instinct rather than reason. By sculpting their heroes with smaller, controlled proportions, artists reinforced the idea that these figures represented the highest ideals of civilisation.

Practical and Social Factors

Beyond artistic ideals, practical concerns played a role:

Durability – Delicate features were prone to breakage in marble sculptures.
Aesthetic focus – Sculptors wanted attention on the entire form, not one exaggerated element.
Changing modesty standards – Some statues were later altered or covered to align with evolving cultural norms.

Modern Shifts in Perception

Today’s association between masculinity and size is a modern cultural shift influenced by media and advertising. In contrast, ancient ideals valued intellect, discipline, and proportion over physical exaggeration.

Classical male statues reflect more than artistic choices – they reveal how societies define beauty, power, and virtue. Their understated masculinity wasn’t a flaw but a carefully crafted statement of what it meant to be an ideal man.

Final Thoughts

Walking through Florence and observing these male statues in person brings history, mythology, and Renaissance art to life. The debate over classical art’s depiction of masculinity continues to fascinate modern audiences, revealing how cultural values shift over time.

So next time you find yourself admiring a classical sculpture, remember – it’s not just about aesthetics. It’s about history, symbolism, and the artistic ideals of the time.

Pin It

About: Lisa Bundesen

Hi, I’m Lisa, a 50+ retired chartered accountant. My husband, Darren, and I explore the world every opportunity we get. Staying fit is key to our adventures, from hiking the Inca Trail to scuba diving. We call Australia home but travel overseas often, always eager to discover new cultures, bustling cities, cuisines, nature and wildlife.

We would love you to join us on our journeys and hope that our adventures give you encouragement to explore this amazing world.

Some of the links below are affiliate links, meaning, at no additional cost to you, I will earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. This helps me to keep bringing you travel updates and news.

I only recommend companies and products that I personally use.